Суэцкий кризис 1956 г. - поворотный момент британской внешней политики?

Главная

Статья в Elpub

РУС ENG

Вестник Томского государственного университета. 2016; : 156-164

Суэцкий кризис 1956 г. - поворотный момент британской внешней политики?

Хахалкина Е. В.

https://doi.org/ 10.17223/15617793/404/25

Аннотация

Суэцкий кризис 1956 г. до сих пор вызывает пристальный интерес отечественных и зарубежных историков. Автор, обращаясь к истории англо-франко-израильской интервенции, выстраивает материал статьи вокруг поиска ответа на вопрос о том, можно ли считать события осени 1956 г. поворотным моментом британской внешней политики. Такая постановка проблемы обусловлена появлением так называемого ревизионистского направления в британской историографии, в рамках которого был представлен новый взгляд на события, связанные с Суэцким кризисом 1956 г.

Список литературы

1. Ближневосточный конфликт : Из документов архива внешней политики РФ, 1947-1967 гг.: в 2 т. / отв. ред. В.В. Наумкин. М., 2003. Т. 1.

2. BDEE. Series A. Vol. 3. The Conservative Government and the End of Empire. 1951-1957. Part 1. L., 1994.

3. The National Archives (United Kingdom). Cabinet Papers (CAB). CAB 128-30. 24 January 1956.

4. Беляев И.П., Примаков Е.М. Египет: время президента Насера. М., 1981.

5. Churchill R. The Rise and Fall of Sir Anthony Eden. L., 1959.

6. CAB 128-28. 7 March 1955.

7. Внешняя политика стран Ближнего и Среднего Востока. М., 1984.

8. Notle R., Polk W. Toward the Policy for the Middle East // Foreign Affairs. 1958. Vol. 36, № 4. P. 645-658.

9. Примаков Е.М., Арутюнов Р. А. Поучительный урок. М., 1957.

10. Sked A., Cook C. Post-war Britain. A. Political history. N.Y., 1979.

11. Aster S. Anthony Eden. Introduction by A.J.P. Taylor. N.Y., 1976.

12. Филитов А.М. Д.Т. Шепилов: министр - нонконформист // Известные дипломаты России : министры иностранных дел. XX век. М., 2007.

13. Румянцев В.П. Ближневосточная политика США и Великобритании в 1956-1960 гг. Томск, 2010.

14. Насер Г. А. Проблемы египетской революции. Избранные речи и выступления. 1952-1970. М., 1979.

15. Hartmann F. The relations of nations. N.Y., 1957.

16. Суэцкий канал. Сборник документов. М., 1957.

17. Gamble A. The Conservative Nation. N.Y., 1974.

18. Пелипась М.Я. Скованные одной цепью: США и Великобритания на Ближнем и Среднем Востоке в 1945-1956 гг. Томск, 2003.

19. Scardon Ph.C. A Lesson for Our Times: How America kept Peace in the Hungary-Suez Crisis of 1956. Commemorating an Historic Turning Point in the Cold War. N.Y., 2010.

20. Мемуары Антони Идена // Международная жизнь. 1960. № 5. С. 120-166.

21. Медведко Л.И. К востоку и западу от Суэца : (Закат колониализма и маневры неоколониализма на Арабском Востоке). М., 1980.

22. Стыкалин А.С. Восточная Европа в системе отношений Восток-Запад (1953 - начало 1960-х гг.) // Холодная война. 1945-1963 гг. Историческая ретроспектива : сб. ст. М., 2003.

23. Контлер Л. История Венгрии. Тысячелетие в центре Европы. М., 2002.

24. Гайдук И.В. В лабиринтах холодной войны : СССР и США в ООН, 1945-1965 гг. М., 2012.

25. Johnson P. The Suez war. N.Y., 1957.

26. Hathaway R. M. Great Britain and the United States. Special Relations since World War II. Boston, 1990.

27. Brown S. The faces of power. Constancy and change in United States foreign policy from Truman to Johnson. N.Y., 1968.

28. Красильников А.Н. Внешняя политика Англии и лейбористская партия (1951-1964). М., 1968.

29. Reassessing Suez 1956. New Perspectives on the Crisis and its Aftermath / ed. by S.C. Smith. Aldershot, 2008.

30. Smith S. America in Britain's place?: Anglo-American Relations and the Middle East in the aftermath of the Suez Crisis // Journal of Transatlantic Relations. 2012. Vol. 10, № 3. P. 252-270.

31. Ashton N. Harold Macmillan and the "Golden Days" of Anglo-American Relations Revisited, 1957-1963 // Diplomatic History. 2005. Vol. 29, № 4. September. P. 691-723.

32. Idem. A special relationship sometimes in spite of ourselves: Britain and Jordan, 1957-1973 // The Journal of Imperial and Commonwealth History. 2005. Vol. 33, № 2. May. P. 221-244.

33. Idem. Britain and the Kuwaiti Crisis 1961 // Diplomacy and Statecraf. 1998. Vol. 9, № 1. March. P. 163-181.

34. Economist. The Suez Crisis. An affair to remember. 27 July 2006.

35. Prime Ministers and Politics Timeline. URL: http://www.bbc.co.uk/history/british/pm_and_pol_tl_01.shtml (data accessed: 09.11.2015).

Tomsk State University Journal. 2016; : 156-164

The Suez Crisis of 1956: a turning point of the British foreign policy?

Khakhalkina E. V.

https://doi.org/ 10.17223/15617793/404/25

Abstract

The Suez Crisis of 1956 still attracts a keen interest of domestic and foreign, especially British, historians. The first decade of the 21st century noted a surge of monographs and articles devoted to a comprehensive and thorough study of the events of the autumn of 1956. This situation, first of all, refers to Western historiography; however, Russian historical science, responding to the opening of the archives of the United Kingdom and other countries, had new fundamental publications related to the history of the triple Anglo-French-Israeli intervention in 1956. In describing the events of the autumn of 1956, the author also touches upon the Hungarian Crisis that coincided with the triple Anglo-French-Israel intervention and had a significant impact on the discussion of the events in the area of the Suez Canal in the Security Council and the General Assembly of the United Nations. Particular attention is paid to the reaction of the USA and the USSR on the Suez and Hungarian Crises. For the first time during the Cold War, Moscow and Washington were on the same side against the colonial powers and strongly condemned the military action against Egypt. At the same time, the White House could not use unrest in Hungary for propaganda purposes. The author, referring to the history of the events of the summer and autumn of 1956, builds material of the article around a search for an answer to the question of whether it is possible to consider the events of the autumn of 1956 a turning point of the British foreign policy. This formulation of the problem is due to the advent of the so-called revisionist trend in British historiography which presented a new view of events related to the implementation and consequences of the Suez operation against Egypt in 1956. Revisionists deny the Suez Crisis as a line after which the British policy in the Near and Middle East changed dramatically. However, questions remain about the impact of the events of the autumn of 1956 on the colonial policy and other areas of foreign policy of Britain. For the UK, the crisis highlighted the need to rethink the chosen strategy not only in the Middle East, but also in the matters of decolonization, which at the turn of the 1950s and 1960s acquired a prompt character in connection with the strengthening of the so-called "non-aligned movement" and the growth of the Asian and African countries in the UN. The Suez crisis had a clear impact on the political crisis in the country and had an important psychological impact on the perception of the country by the population and by the political elite. In the early 1957, Prime Minister Anthony Eden resigned and H. Macmillan became a new head of government. He put forward new initiatives in the field of colonial and European policy. A new chapter began in British history.

References

1. Blizhnevostochnyi konflikt : Iz dokumentov arkhiva vneshnei politiki RF, 1947-1967 gg.: v 2 t. / otv. red. V.V. Naumkin. M., 2003. T. 1.

2. BDEE. Series A. Vol. 3. The Conservative Government and the End of Empire. 1951-1957. Part 1. L., 1994.

3. The National Archives (United Kingdom). Cabinet Papers (CAB). CAB 128-30. 24 January 1956.

4. Belyaev I.P., Primakov E.M. Egipet: vremya prezidenta Nasera. M., 1981.

5. Churchill R. The Rise and Fall of Sir Anthony Eden. L., 1959.

6. CAB 128-28. 7 March 1955.

7. Vneshnyaya politika stran Blizhnego i Srednego Vostoka. M., 1984.

8. Notle R., Polk W. Toward the Policy for the Middle East // Foreign Affairs. 1958. Vol. 36, № 4. P. 645-658.

9. Primakov E.M., Arutyunov R. A. Pouchitel'nyi urok. M., 1957.

10. Sked A., Cook C. Post-war Britain. A. Political history. N.Y., 1979.

11. Aster S. Anthony Eden. Introduction by A.J.P. Taylor. N.Y., 1976.

12. Filitov A.M. D.T. Shepilov: ministr - nonkonformist // Izvestnye diplomaty Rossii : ministry inostrannykh del. XX vek. M., 2007.

13. Rumyantsev V.P. Blizhnevostochnaya politika SShA i Velikobritanii v 1956-1960 gg. Tomsk, 2010.

14. Naser G. A. Problemy egipetskoi revolyutsii. Izbrannye rechi i vystupleniya. 1952-1970. M., 1979.

15. Hartmann F. The relations of nations. N.Y., 1957.

16. Suetskii kanal. Sbornik dokumentov. M., 1957.

17. Gamble A. The Conservative Nation. N.Y., 1974.

18. Pelipas' M.Ya. Skovannye odnoi tsep'yu: SShA i Velikobritaniya na Blizhnem i Srednem Vostoke v 1945-1956 gg. Tomsk, 2003.

19. Scardon Ph.C. A Lesson for Our Times: How America kept Peace in the Hungary-Suez Crisis of 1956. Commemorating an Historic Turning Point in the Cold War. N.Y., 2010.

20. Memuary Antoni Idena // Mezhdunarodnaya zhizn'. 1960. № 5. S. 120-166.

21. Medvedko L.I. K vostoku i zapadu ot Suetsa : (Zakat kolonializma i manevry neokolonializma na Arabskom Vostoke). M., 1980.

22. Stykalin A.S. Vostochnaya Evropa v sisteme otnoshenii Vostok-Zapad (1953 - nachalo 1960-kh gg.) // Kholodnaya voina. 1945-1963 gg. Istoricheskaya retrospektiva : sb. st. M., 2003.

23. Kontler L. Istoriya Vengrii. Tysyacheletie v tsentre Evropy. M., 2002.

24. Gaiduk I.V. V labirintakh kholodnoi voiny : SSSR i SShA v OON, 1945-1965 gg. M., 2012.

25. Johnson P. The Suez war. N.Y., 1957.

26. Hathaway R. M. Great Britain and the United States. Special Relations since World War II. Boston, 1990.

27. Brown S. The faces of power. Constancy and change in United States foreign policy from Truman to Johnson. N.Y., 1968.

28. Krasil'nikov A.N. Vneshnyaya politika Anglii i leiboristskaya partiya (1951-1964). M., 1968.

29. Reassessing Suez 1956. New Perspectives on the Crisis and its Aftermath / ed. by S.C. Smith. Aldershot, 2008.

30. Smith S. America in Britain's place?: Anglo-American Relations and the Middle East in the aftermath of the Suez Crisis // Journal of Transatlantic Relations. 2012. Vol. 10, № 3. P. 252-270.

31. Ashton N. Harold Macmillan and the "Golden Days" of Anglo-American Relations Revisited, 1957-1963 // Diplomatic History. 2005. Vol. 29, № 4. September. P. 691-723.

32. Idem. A special relationship sometimes in spite of ourselves: Britain and Jordan, 1957-1973 // The Journal of Imperial and Commonwealth History. 2005. Vol. 33, № 2. May. P. 221-244.

33. Idem. Britain and the Kuwaiti Crisis 1961 // Diplomacy and Statecraf. 1998. Vol. 9, № 1. March. P. 163-181.

34. Economist. The Suez Crisis. An affair to remember. 27 July 2006.

35. Prime Ministers and Politics Timeline. URL: http://www.bbc.co.uk/history/british/pm_and_pol_tl_01.shtml (data accessed: 09.11.2015).

Суэцкий кризис 1956 г. - поворотный момент британской внешней политики?

Аннотация

The Suez Crisis of 1956: a turning point of the British foreign policy?

Abstract

События