Ноябрьская революция 1918 г. в Германии и проблемы возникновения, развития и падения Веймарской республики

Главная

Статья в Elpub

РУС ENG

Вестник Томского государственного университета. 2018; : 223-228

Ноябрьская революция 1918 г. в Германии и проблемы возникновения, развития и падения Веймарской республики

Шульц Э. Э.

https://doi.org/10.17223/15617793/426/27

Аннотация

Рассматривается история Веймарской республики через призму алгоритма Немецкой революции. Сравнительно-исторический анализ позволяет выявить общие черты Немецкой революции и Веймарской республики с событиями Великой Французской революции, революции во Франции 1848 г. и революции в России 1917-1922 гг. Автор приходит к выводу, что Веймарская республика стала таким же периодом революционного развития Германии, как и Первая республика во Франции, что обусловило ее историю, многие закономерности ее возникновения, развития и падения.

Список литературы

1. Шульц Э.Э. Теория революции: революции и современные цивилизации. М. : ЛЕНАНД, 2016. 400 с.

2. Шульц Э.Э. От Веймарской республики к Третьему рейху: Электоральная история. Германии 1920-х - начала 1930-х гг. М. : ЛЕНАНД, 2016. 272 с.

3. Патрушев А.И. Германия в XX веке. М. : Дрофа, 2004. 432 с.

4. Шульц Э.Э. «Левый» и «правый» бунт в Германии 1920-30-х гг.: истоки, ход событий, результаты. Барнаул : Издательская группа «Сипресс», 2014. 149 с.

5. Шульц Э.Э. Технологии бунта (Технологии управления радикальными формами социального протеста в политическом контексте). М. : Подольская фабрика офсетной печати, 2014. 512 с.

6. Арендт Х. О революции. М. : Европа, 2011. 664 с.

7. Rosenstock-Huessy E. Revolution as a Political Concept // Revolutions: Finished and Unfinished, From Primal to Final / ed. by Paul Caringella, Wayne Cristaudo, Glenn Hughes. Cambridge Scholars Publishing, 2012. P. 1-7.

8. Schrecker J.E. The Chinese Revolution in Historical Perspective. Greenwood Publishing Group, 2004.

9. Selbin E. Revolution, rebellion, resistance: the power of story. London; New York : Zed Books, 2010.

10. Herzberger L. The Structure of Thermidor: Some Case Studies. Xlibris Corporation, 2007. 344 p.

11. Kater M.H. The Nazi Party. A Social Profile of Members and Leaders 1919-1945. Cambridge, Massachusetts : Harvard University Press, 1983. 415 p.

12. Lukacs J. The Hitler of History. N.Y. : Vintage Books, 1998. 279 p.

13. Нольте Э. Фашизм в его эпохе / пер. с нем. Новосибирск : Сибирский хронограф, 2001. 568 c.

14. Артамошин С.В. Понятия и позиции консервативной революции: интеллектуальное течение «консервативной революции» в политической жизни Веймарской республики. Брянск, 2011. 312 с.

15. Ватлин А.Ю. Германия в XX веке. М. : РОССПЭН, 2002. 336 с.

16. Сегалл Я.Е. Очерки экономической политики германского фашизма. М. : Гос. соц.-эк. изд-во, 1934. 106 с.

17. Михельс Р. Демократическая аристократия и аристократическая демократия // Социс. 2000. № 1. С. 107-116.

18. Красин Ю.А. Революцией устрашенные. Критический очерк буржуазных концепций социальной революции. М. : Политиздат, 1975. 366 с.

19. Johari J.C. Contemporary Political Theory: New Dimensions, Basic Concepts and Major Trends. Sterling Publishers Pvt. Ltd, 1987. 756 p.

20. Freyer H. Revolution from the Right // The Weimar Republic Sourcebook / ed. by Anton Kaes, Martin Jay, Edward Dimendberg. University of California Press, 1994. P. 347-348.

21. Lapp B. Revolution from the Right: Politics, Class and the Rise of Nazism in Saxony. Brill, 1997. 248 p.

22. Mosse G.L. Masses and Man: Nationalist and Fascist Perceptions of Reality. Wayne State University Press, 1987. 362 p.

23. Brinton С. The Anatomy of Revolution. Revised and Expanded Edition. N.Y. : Vintage Books, 1965. 310 p.

24. Meisel J.H. Counter-revolution: how revolutions die. Atherton Press, 1966. 237 p.

25. Zagorin P. Rebels and Rulers, 1500-1600: Volume 1, Agrarian and Urban Rebellions: Society, States, and Early Modern Revolution. Cambridge University Press, 1982. 292 p.

26. Calvert P. Revolution and Counter-Revolution Concepts in the Social Sciences. Milton Keynes : Open University Press, 1990. 90 p.

27. Housden M. Hitler. Study of a revolutionary. London ; New York : Routledge, 2000. 220 p.

28. Weber E. Revolution? Counterrevolution? What revolution? // Fascism, a Reader's Guide: Analyses, Interpretations, Bibliography / ed. by Walter Laqueur. University of California Press, 1978. P. 435-468.

29. Dutt R.P. Fascism and Social Revolution. Wildside Press LLC, 2009. 320 p.

30. Taylor S. Germany, 1918-1933: revolution, counter-revolution and the rise of Hitler. Duckworth, 1983. 131 p.

31. Шульц Э.Э. «Моделирование революций» (к дискуссии о стадиях) // Историческая психология и социология истории. 2015. № 2. С. 158-173.

32. Хобсбаум Э. Эпоха крайностей: Короткий двадцатый век (1914-1991). М. : Независимая газета, 2004. 632 с.

33. Dahrendorf R. Society and Democracy in Germany. New York : Doubleday, 1967. 457 p.

34. Saunders T. Nazism and Social Revolution // Modern Germany Reconsidered: 1870-1945 / ed. by Gordon Martel. Taylor & Francis, 1992. P. 159-177.

35. Нольте Э. Европейская гражданская война (1917-1945). Национал-социализм и большевизм : пер. с нем. М. : Логос, 2003. 527 с.

36. Ellul J. Autopsy of Revolution. N.Y. : Knopf, 1971. 300 p.

37. Троцкий Л.Д. Бонапартизм и фашизм: К характеристике современного положения в Европе. URL: http://revkom.com/biblioteka/ marxism/trotckii/1934bonapart.htm (дата обращения: 16.07.2015).

Tomsk State University Journal. 2018; : 223-228

The November Revolution of 1918 in Germany and problems of emergence, development and falling of the Weimar Republic

Shults E. E.

https://doi.org/10.17223/15617793/426/27

Abstract

The article aims to consider the history of the Weimar Republic through the prism of the algorithm of the German revolution (that began in November, 1918 and is known as the November Revolution) and its continuation that discloses regularities of the origin, development and disappearance of the first German democracy. A comparative-historical approach to the German revolution (1918-1923), the Great French revolution (1789-1799), the French revolution of 1848, the Russian revolution (1917-1922), the events of the Italian history of the period of Mussolini, the Spanish Franco's period, the Portuguese history from 1926 to 1974 has become the cornerstone of the analysis. The author divides the German revolution into three stages: 1918-1923, 1924-1929, 193033. The first stage lasted from the revolt in Kiel (November 3-10, 1918) to the "beer putsch" in Munich and the revolt of communists in Hamburg in November, 1923. The open civil war in the country ended at that stage: the social protest splashed out in the streets, led to mass demonstrations, strikes and disorders, but not to revolts and big armed conflicts. This protest fell down during the economic stabilization of 1926-1928, but it began to rise again with the world economic crisis of 1929. The second stage (1924-1929) came to an end with the beginning of the world economic crisis. The third stage was connected with the new aggravation of opposition in the German society which led to the polarization and radicalization of society and, eventually, to the rise of the Nazis to power. The analysis shows that the German revolution has common features with the French revolution of 1848 and the Russian revolution in its February-October stage. Besides, the German revolution of 1918-1923 and the subsequent history of the Weimar Republic has broad analogies with the Great French and Russian revolutions in the stages known as the Thermidor and the Bonapartist regime. The author comes to a conclusion that events of the end of 1923 in Germany can be regarded as the Thermidor - a kickback of the revolution to the right, and Hitler's coming to power could be qualified as the Bonapartist regime. This period of the German history finds analogies in contemporary events: the Italian history of the period of Mussolini, Spain in Franco's period, the Portuguese history from 1926 to 1974. The author comes to a conclusion that the Weimar Republic became the same period of revolutionary development of Germany as the First Republic in France, which caused its history, many regularities of its emergence, development and falling.

References

1. Shul'ts E.E. Teoriya revolyutsii: revolyutsii i sovremennye tsivilizatsii. M. : LENAND, 2016. 400 s.

2. Shul'ts E.E. Ot Veimarskoi respubliki k Tret'emu reikhu: Elektoral'naya istoriya. Germanii 1920-kh - nachala 1930-kh gg. M. : LENAND, 2016. 272 s.

3. Patrushev A.I. Germaniya v XX veke. M. : Drofa, 2004. 432 s.

4. Shul'ts E.E. «Levyi» i «pravyi» bunt v Germanii 1920-30-kh gg.: istoki, khod sobytii, rezul'taty. Barnaul : Izdatel'skaya gruppa «Sipress», 2014. 149 s.

5. Shul'ts E.E. Tekhnologii bunta (Tekhnologii upravleniya radikal'nymi formami sotsial'nogo protesta v politicheskom kontekste). M. : Podol'skaya fabrika ofsetnoi pechati, 2014. 512 s.

6. Arendt Kh. O revolyutsii. M. : Evropa, 2011. 664 s.

8. Schrecker J.E. The Chinese Revolution in Historical Perspective. Greenwood Publishing Group, 2004.

9. Selbin E. Revolution, rebellion, resistance: the power of story. London; New York : Zed Books, 2010.

10. Herzberger L. The Structure of Thermidor: Some Case Studies. Xlibris Corporation, 2007. 344 p.

11. Kater M.H. The Nazi Party. A Social Profile of Members and Leaders 1919-1945. Cambridge, Massachusetts : Harvard University Press, 1983. 415 p.

12. Lukacs J. The Hitler of History. N.Y. : Vintage Books, 1998. 279 p.

13. Nol'te E. Fashizm v ego epokhe / per. s nem. Novosibirsk : Sibirskii khronograf, 2001. 568 c.

14. Artamoshin S.V. Ponyatiya i pozitsii konservativnoi revolyutsii: intellektual'noe techenie «konservativnoi revolyutsii» v politicheskoi zhizni Veimarskoi respubliki. Bryansk, 2011. 312 s.

15. Vatlin A.Yu. Germaniya v XX veke. M. : ROSSPEN, 2002. 336 s.

16. Segall Ya.E. Ocherki ekonomicheskoi politiki germanskogo fashizma. M. : Gos. sots.-ek. izd-vo, 1934. 106 s.

17. Mikhel's R. Demokraticheskaya aristokratiya i aristokraticheskaya demokratiya // Sotsis. 2000. № 1. S. 107-116.

18. Krasin Yu.A. Revolyutsiei ustrashennye. Kriticheskii ocherk burzhuaznykh kontseptsii sotsial'noi revolyutsii. M. : Politizdat, 1975. 366 s.

19. Johari J.C. Contemporary Political Theory: New Dimensions, Basic Concepts and Major Trends. Sterling Publishers Pvt. Ltd, 1987. 756 p.

20. Freyer H. Revolution from the Right // The Weimar Republic Sourcebook / ed. by Anton Kaes, Martin Jay, Edward Dimendberg. University of California Press, 1994. P. 347-348.

21. Lapp B. Revolution from the Right: Politics, Class and the Rise of Nazism in Saxony. Brill, 1997. 248 p.

22. Mosse G.L. Masses and Man: Nationalist and Fascist Perceptions of Reality. Wayne State University Press, 1987. 362 p.

23. Brinton S. The Anatomy of Revolution. Revised and Expanded Edition. N.Y. : Vintage Books, 1965. 310 p.

24. Meisel J.H. Counter-revolution: how revolutions die. Atherton Press, 1966. 237 p.

25. Zagorin P. Rebels and Rulers, 1500-1600: Volume 1, Agrarian and Urban Rebellions: Society, States, and Early Modern Revolution. Cambridge University Press, 1982. 292 p.

26. Calvert P. Revolution and Counter-Revolution Concepts in the Social Sciences. Milton Keynes : Open University Press, 1990. 90 p.

27. Housden M. Hitler. Study of a revolutionary. London ; New York : Routledge, 2000. 220 p.

29. Dutt R.P. Fascism and Social Revolution. Wildside Press LLC, 2009. 320 p.

30. Taylor S. Germany, 1918-1933: revolution, counter-revolution and the rise of Hitler. Duckworth, 1983. 131 p.

31. Shul'ts E.E. «Modelirovanie revolyutsii» (k diskussii o stadiyakh) // Istoricheskaya psikhologiya i sotsiologiya istorii. 2015. № 2. S. 158-173.

32. Khobsbaum E. Epokha krainostei: Korotkii dvadtsatyi vek (1914-1991). M. : Nezavisimaya gazeta, 2004. 632 s.

33. Dahrendorf R. Society and Democracy in Germany. New York : Doubleday, 1967. 457 p.

34. Saunders T. Nazism and Social Revolution // Modern Germany Reconsidered: 1870-1945 / ed. by Gordon Martel. Taylor & Francis, 1992. P. 159-177.

35. Nol'te E. Evropeiskaya grazhdanskaya voina (1917-1945). Natsional-sotsializm i bol'shevizm : per. s nem. M. : Logos, 2003. 527 s.

36. Ellul J. Autopsy of Revolution. N.Y. : Knopf, 1971. 300 p.

37. Trotskii L.D. Bonapartizm i fashizm: K kharakteristike sovremennogo polozheniya v Evrope. URL: http://revkom.com/biblioteka/ marxism/trotckii/1934bonapart.htm (data obrashcheniya: 16.07.2015).

Ноябрьская революция 1918 г. в Германии и проблемы возникновения, развития и падения Веймарской республики

Аннотация

The November Revolution of 1918 in Germany and problems of emergence, development and falling of the Weimar Republic

Abstract

События

EasyCookieInfo