Журналов:     Статей:        

Ориенталистика. 2021; 4: 150-189

Связь Фустат ал-‘адала с Сийар ал-мулук: текстологический анализ

Хисматулин Алексей Александрович

https://doi.org/10.31696/2618-7043-2021-4-1-150-189

Аннотация

Бюрократическая система Великих Салджуков (431–552/1040–1157) достигла апогея своего развития в связи с обширными завоеваниями и необходимостью эффективно управлять завоёванными территориями. Эта система сохранилась у их анатолийских преемников (ок. 483–707/1081–1308) вместе со способами продвижения по административной карьерной лестнице. Наряду с наследственной преемственностью при государственных назначениях создание литературных подделок, скрытый плагиат и преднамеренное редактирование чужих текстов ради получения высокой должности при дворе Салджукидов занимали среди этих способов не последнее место. Эти способы ярко характеризуют как жанр административной литературы, так и работавших в нём авторов, а структура и содержание их компиляций в данном жанре напрямую зависели от вакансий, на которые они претендовали.

Фустат ал-‘адала органично вписывается в ряд других текстов, созданных в жанре административной литературы в эпоху Салджукидов. Как показал текстологический анализ, проведённый в данной статье, компилятор Фустат ал- ‘адала прибегнул к скрытому плагиату объёмных фрагментов из разножанровых источников, а также – к их преднамеренному редактированию с целью получить должность при дворе Музаффар ал-дина б. Алп Йурака (ум. 691/1292) – военачальника и правителя бейлика Чубанидов с административным центром в Кастамону. Одним из базовых источников для этой компиляции послужила первая редакция Сийар ал-мулук / Сийасат-нама, которая была сфабрикована Амиром Му‘иззи приблизительно за 185 лет до того и приписана им Низам ал-мулку с той же целью – получить высокую должность при дворе Салджукидов. 

Список литературы

1. De Nicola, Bruno. The Fustat al-‘Adala: A Unique Manuscript on the Reli-gious Landscape of Medieval Anatolia. In: A.C.S. Peacock & Sara Nur Yıldız (eds.) Islamic Literature and Intellectual Life in Fourteenth- and Fifteenth-Century Anatolia. Würzburg: Ergon Verlag; 2016. P. 49–72; available at: https://goldsmiths.academia.edu/BrunoDeNicola.

2. Де Никола, Бруно. Фустат ал-‘адала: уникальная рукопись о религиозном ландшафте средневековой Анатолии. Ориенталистика. 2021;4(1):121–147. https://doi.org/10.31696/2618-7043-2021-4-1-121-147

3. Хисматулин, А. Оригиналы и подделки в книжной серии «Назидательная литература эпохи Салджукидов на персидском языке». Ориенталистика. 2020;3(2): 497–536; available at: https://www.orientalistica.com/jour/article/view/242

4. Khismatulin, A. The Persian Mirrors for Princes Written in the Saljuq Period: the Book Series. Vestnik of Saint Petersburg University. Asian and African Studies, 2019;11(3): 321–344; available at: https://aasjournal.spbu.ru/article/view/6176

5. Davarpanah, Hormoz. Mo‘ezzi Nišāburi. In: Encyclopædia Iranica, online edn., available at: http://www.iranicaonline.org/articles/moezzi-nisaburi

6. Durand-Guédy, David. Malekšah. In: Encyclopædia Iranica, online edn., available at: http://www.iranicaonline.org/articles/maleksah

7. Eder, M., Rybicki, J. and Kestemont, M. Stylometry with R: a package for computational text analysis. R Journal, 8(1): 107–121; available at: https://journal.r-project.org/archive/2016/RJ-2016-007/index.html

8. Хисматулин, А. Амир Му‘иззи Нишапури. Сийасат-нама / Сийар ал-мулук («Книга о правлении/Жития владык»): подделка, приписанная Низам ал-мулку. Серия: Назидательная литература эпохи Салджукидов на персидском языке: Оригиналы и подделки (I). СПб.: Петербургское Востоковедение; М.: Садра; 2020; available at: https://orientalstudies.academia.edu/AlexeyKhismatulin

9. Muhammad al-Khatib. Fustat al-‘adala fi-qawa‘id al-saltana. Bibliothèque nationale de France, MS Supplemént Turc 1120; (In Persian); available at: https://gallica.bnf.fr/ark:/12148/btv1b10082524b/f1.item.zoom

10. Siasset naméh. Traité de gouvernement composé pour le sultan Seldjoukide Melik-châh par le vizir Nizam oul-Moulk. Texte persan et traduction française, ed. par Charles Schefer. Paris: éditeur Ernest Leroux; 1891 (T. I. Texte persan); 1893 (T. II. Traduction française et notes); available at: https://archive.org/details/siassetnamhtra01nizauoft.

11. Turan, Osman. Selçuk Türkiye’si Din Tarihine Dair Bir Kaynak: Fustatü’l-adale fi kavaidü’s-saltana”. In: 60. Doğum Yılı Münasebetiyle Fuad Köprülü Armağanı. İstanbul: Osman Yalçın Matbaası; 1953. P. 531–564; 2nd edn.: Ankara: Türk Tarih Kurumu; 2010. (In Turkish and Persian).

12. Yusufi, Muhammad ‘Ali. Dar astana-yi tahqiq wa nashr: Fustat al-‘adala fi qawa‘id al-saltana. Faslnama-yi Ayina-yi mirath 2001;4(1): 56–58; available at: http://www.mirasmaktoob.ir/sites/default/files/archive/pdf/A13-Yoosefi-Edalat.pdf

13. Nizam al-Mulk. Siyar al-muluk (Siyasat-nama), ed. Mahmud ‘Abidi. Te-hran: Nashr-i sukhan; 1398/2019. (In Persian).

14. Danishyar, Murtaza. Siyar al-muluk-i Nizam al-Mulk: aghlat, maj‘ulat wa ‘amil-i anha. Pazhuhish-nama-yi tarikh-i tamaddun-i islami 1398/2019;52(1): 25–57; (In Persian); available at: https://journals.ut.ac.ir/article_75207.html

15. Ghereghlou, Kioumars. Kašf al-zonun. In: Encyclopædia Iranica, online edn.; available at: https://iranicaonline.org/articles/kasf-al-zonun

16. Hajji Khalifa. Kashf al-zunun ‘an asami al-kutub wa-l-funun. Bayrut: Dar Ihya’ al-turath al-‘arabi; 1941. (In Arabic); online edn. available at: https://al-maktaba.org/book/2118/9281

17. Khismatulin, A. Islamic Education Reflected in the Forms of Medieval Scholarly Literature: Jam‘, Ta’lif, and Tasnif in Classical Islam. In: Sebastian Günther (ed.). Knowledge and Education in Classical Islam: Religious Learning between Continuity and Change. Leiden: Brill; 2019. In 2 vols., i, p. 475–487; available at: https://orientalstudies.academia.edu/AlexeyKhismatulin

18. Хисматулин, А. Сочинения имама ал-Газали. СПб.: Петербургское востоковедение; М.: Садра; 2017. Серия: Назидательная литература эпохи Салджукидов на персидском языке: Оригиналы и подделки (II); available at: https://orientalstudies.academia.edu/AlexeyKhismatulin

19. [Al-Ghazali, Muhammad.] Makatib-i farsi-yi Ghazzali ba nam-i Faza’il al-anam min rasa’il Hujjat al-Islam. Gardawaranda-yi yaki az mansuban-i wai, ed. by ‘Abbas Iqbal Ashtiyani. Tehran; 1363/1984. (In Persian).

20. Al-Kiya al-Harasi at web-site Markaz Abi’l-Hasan al-Ash‘ari. (In Arabic); available at: https://web.archive.org/web/20160304142312/http://www.achaari.ma/Article.aspx?C=5714

21. Al-Farisi, ‘Abd al-Ghafir. Al-Mukhtasar min kitab al-Siyaq li-Tarikh Nisabur, ed. Muhammad Kazim al-Mahmudi. Tehran: Markaz-i pazhuhishi-yi Mirath-i maktub; 1384/2005; (In Arabic); available at: https://ketabpedia.com/تحميل/المختصر-من-كتاب-السياق-لتاريخ-نيسابور/

22. Ibn Khallikan. Wafayat al-A‘yan wa Anba’ Abna’ al-Zaman. Bayrut; 1900-… (In Arabic); online edn. available at: https://al-maktaba.org/book/1000/1299#p1

23. ‘Abbas Iqbal Ashtiyani. Wazarat dar ‘ahd-i salatin-i buzurg-i Saljuqi az tarikh-i tashkil-i in silsila ta marg-i sultan-i Sanjar (432–552), ed. by M.-T. Danishpazhuh wa Y. Dhuka’. Tehran; 1338/1959. (In Persian).

24. Al-Dhahabi, Shams al-din. Siyar a‘lam al-nubala. Mu’assasat al-risala; 1405/1985; (In Arabic); online edn. available at: http://lib.eshia.ir/40384/19/351

25. Makdisi, George. Muslim institutions of learning in eleventh-century Baghdad. Bulletin of the SOAS 1961;24(1): 1–56.

26. Simidchieva, Marta. Kingship and Legitimacy in Nizam al-Mulk’s Siyasatnama, Fifth/Eleventh Century. In: Beatrice Gruendler & Louise Marlow (eds.). Writers and Rulers, Perspective on Their Relationship from Abbasid to Safavid Times. Wiesbaden: Reichert Verlag; 2004. P. 97–131; available at: https://yorku.academia.edu/MartaSimidchieva

27. Hanaway, William L. Secretaries, Poets, and the Literary Language. In: Brian Spooner & William L. Hanaway (eds.). Literacy in the Persianate World Writing and the Social Order. University of Pennsylvania Press; 2012. P. 95–142.

28. ‘Oudi, Sattar, & Murtaza Baqayi. Nigahi ba sarguzasht-i Ibn ‘Alqami, wapasin wazir-i shi‘ayi-yi ‘Abbasiyan. Tarikh-i farhang wa tamaddun-i islami 1391/2012;3(6): 101–120; (In Persian); available at: http://tarikh.maaref.ac.ir/article-1-1202-en.pdf

29. Khuyi, Hasan b. ‘Abd al-Mu’min Husam al-Din. Majmu‘a-yi athar-i Husam al-din Khuyi. Tehran: Mirath-i maktub; 2000. (In Persian).

30. Jackson, P. Ahmad Takudar. In: Encyclopædia Iranica, online edn.; available at: https://iranicaonline.org/articles/ahmad-takudar-third-il-khan-of-iran-r

31. Turan, Osman. Türkiye Selçukluları Hakkında Resmi Vesikalar. Ankara; 1958. Türk Tarih Kurumu Yayınları VII. Seri, No. 32. (In Turkish and Persian).

32. Aqsarayi, Mahmud b. Muhammad. Tarikh-i Salajiqa ya Musamarat al-akhbar wa musayarat al-akhyar, ed. Osman Turan. Tehran: Asatir; 1362/1983. (In Persian); available at: https://eliteraturebook.com/books/search/all/مسامرة

33. Histoire des Seldjoucides d'Asie Mineure d'après l'abrégé du Seldjouknameh d’Ibn Bibi. In: Recueil de textes relatifs à l'histoire des Seljoucides, iv, par M. Th. Houtsma. Leide: Brill; 1902. available at: https://archive.org/details/recueildetextesr03houtuoft/page/n807/mode/2up

34. Yazici, Tahsin. Ebn Bibi. In: Encyclopædia Iranica, online edn.; available at: http://www.iranicaonline.org/articles/ebn-bibi

35. Bigbabapur, Yusuf. Tuhfat al-muluk athari-yi nawyafta az Awhadi-yi Maraghayi. Ayina-yi mirath 1390/2011;9(48): 21–47; (In Persian); available at: http://ensani.ir/file/download/article/20121231090428-9611-54.pdf

36. Vafayi, Muhammad Afshin. Naqdi bar: Tuhfat al-muluk az Awhadi Maraghi. Bukhara, 1391/2012;15(86): 460–466; (In Persian); available at: https://www.academia.edu/6015292/

37. Al-Quda‘i, Muhammad b. Salama. Tarikh al-Quda‘i [al-ma‘ruf bi-]Kitab ‘Uyun al-ma‘arif wa-funun akhbar al-khala’if, ed. Muhammad al-Misri. Makka; 1415/1995. (In Arabic); available at: https://archive.org/details/1933p.d.f1760

38. Al-Quda‘i, Muhammad b. Salama. Kitab al-inba’ bi-anba’ al-anbiya’ wa-tawarikh al-khulafa’ wa-wilayat al-umara’ al-ma‘ruf bi-Tarikh al-Quda‘i, ed. ‘Umar Tadmuri. Bayrut: al-Maktabat al-‘asriyya; 1999. (In Arabic).

39. Ibn al-‘Imrani, Muhammad b. ‘Ali. Al-inba’ fi-tarikh al-khulafa’, ed. Taqi Binesh. Mashhad: Nashr-i Danish; 1363/1984. (In Arabic).

40. Ibn al-‘Imrani, Muhammad b. ‘Ali. Al-inba’ fi-tarikh al-khulafa’, ed. Qasim al-Samarayi. Qahira: Dar al-afaq al-‘arabiyya; 1419/1999. (In Arabic); available at: https://al-maktaba.org/book/12289

41. Bosworth, C. Administrative literature. In: M. Young, J. Latham, & R. Serjeant (eds.). Religion, Learning and Science in the ‘Abbasid Period. The Cambridge History of Arabic Literature. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 1990. P. 155–167; available at: https://archive.org/details/M.J.L.YoungJ.D.LathamR.B.SerjeantEdsReligionLearningAndScienceInTheAbbasidPeriod

42. Yıldız, Sara Nur. A Nadim for the Sultan. Rawandi and the Anatolian Seljuks. In: Peacock A. C. S. & Sara Nur Yıldız (eds.). The Seljuks of Anatolia: Court and Society in the Medieval Middle East. London; New York: I. B. Tauris; 2013. P. 91–111.

43. Komaily, Mokhtar. Rawandi, intihal ya iqtibas? Ayina-yi mirath 1387/2008;4(43): 150–162; (In Persian); available at: http://www.ensani.ir/fa/content/263519/default.aspx.

44. Orfali, Bilal. Employment opportunities in literature in tenth-century Islamic courts. In: Sabine Schmidtke (ed.). Studying the Near and Middle East at the Institute for Advanced Study, Princeton, 1935—2018, Piscataway, NJ: Gorgias Press; 2018. P. 243–250; available at: https://www.academia.edu/36407420/Employment_Opportunities_in_Literature_in_tenth-Century_Islamic_Courts.

Orientalistica. 2021; 4: 150-189

The Fustat al-‘adala’s relation to the Siyar al-muluk: textual analysis

Khismatulin Alexey A.

https://doi.org/10.31696/2618-7043-2021-4-1-150-189

Abstract

The bureaucratic system of the Great Saljuqs (431–552/1040–1157) reached the apogee of its development in connection with extensive conquests and the need to effectively manage the conquered territories. This system was later preserved by their Anatolian successors (c. 483–707/1081–1308), along with the methods of climbing the administrative career ladder. Along with the hereditary succession in government appointments, the making of literary forgeries, hidden plagiarism and the deliberate editing of texts written by other people occupied not the last place among these methods in order to obtain a high position at the Saljuqid сourt. These methods clearly characterize both the genre of administrative literature and the authors who worked in it. The structure and content of their compilations in this genre directly depended on the vacancies they applied for.
The Fustat al-‘adala organically fits into a number of other texts written in the genre of administrative literature in the Saljuqid era. As shown by the textual analysis in this article, the Fustat al-‘adala’s compiler resorted to hidden plagiarism of voluminous fragments from sources of different genres, as well as to their deliberate editing in order to get a position at the сourt of Muzaffar al-din b. Alp Yurak (d. 691/1292) who was the military commander and ruler of the Chobanids beylik with its administrative center in Kastamonu.
One of the basic sources for this compilation was the first redaction of the Siyar al-muluk (Siyasat-nama), which was fabricated by Amir Mu‘izzi about 185 years before and ascribed by him to Nizam al-mulk also with the aim of obtaining a high position at the Saljuqid сourt.

References

1. De Nicola, Bruno. The Fustat al-‘Adala: A Unique Manuscript on the Reli-gious Landscape of Medieval Anatolia. In: A.C.S. Peacock & Sara Nur Yıldız (eds.) Islamic Literature and Intellectual Life in Fourteenth- and Fifteenth-Century Anatolia. Würzburg: Ergon Verlag; 2016. P. 49–72; available at: https://goldsmiths.academia.edu/BrunoDeNicola.

2. De Nikola, Bruno. Fustat al-‘adala: unikal'naya rukopis' o religioznom landshafte srednevekovoi Anatolii. Orientalistika. 2021;4(1):121–147. https://doi.org/10.31696/2618-7043-2021-4-1-121-147

3. Khismatulin, A. Originaly i poddelki v knizhnoi serii «Nazidatel'naya literatura epokhi Saldzhukidov na persidskom yazyke». Orientalistika. 2020;3(2): 497–536; available at: https://www.orientalistica.com/jour/article/view/242

4. Khismatulin, A. The Persian Mirrors for Princes Written in the Saljuq Period: the Book Series. Vestnik of Saint Petersburg University. Asian and African Studies, 2019;11(3): 321–344; available at: https://aasjournal.spbu.ru/article/view/6176

5. Davarpanah, Hormoz. Mo‘ezzi Nišāburi. In: Encyclopædia Iranica, online edn., available at: http://www.iranicaonline.org/articles/moezzi-nisaburi

6. Durand-Guédy, David. Malekšah. In: Encyclopædia Iranica, online edn., available at: http://www.iranicaonline.org/articles/maleksah

7. Eder, M., Rybicki, J. and Kestemont, M. Stylometry with R: a package for computational text analysis. R Journal, 8(1): 107–121; available at: https://journal.r-project.org/archive/2016/RJ-2016-007/index.html

8. Khismatulin, A. Amir Mu‘izzi Nishapuri. Siiasat-nama / Siiar al-muluk («Kniga o pravlenii/Zhitiya vladyk»): poddelka, pripisannaya Nizam al-mulku. Seriya: Nazidatel'naya literatura epokhi Saldzhukidov na persidskom yazyke: Originaly i poddelki (I). SPb.: Peterburgskoe Vostokovedenie; M.: Sadra; 2020; available at: https://orientalstudies.academia.edu/AlexeyKhismatulin

9. Muhammad al-Khatib. Fustat al-‘adala fi-qawa‘id al-saltana. Bibliothèque nationale de France, MS Supplemént Turc 1120; (In Persian); available at: https://gallica.bnf.fr/ark:/12148/btv1b10082524b/f1.item.zoom

10. Siasset naméh. Traité de gouvernement composé pour le sultan Seldjoukide Melik-châh par le vizir Nizam oul-Moulk. Texte persan et traduction française, ed. par Charles Schefer. Paris: éditeur Ernest Leroux; 1891 (T. I. Texte persan); 1893 (T. II. Traduction française et notes); available at: https://archive.org/details/siassetnamhtra01nizauoft.

11. Turan, Osman. Selçuk Türkiye’si Din Tarihine Dair Bir Kaynak: Fustatü’l-adale fi kavaidü’s-saltana”. In: 60. Doğum Yılı Münasebetiyle Fuad Köprülü Armağanı. İstanbul: Osman Yalçın Matbaası; 1953. P. 531–564; 2nd edn.: Ankara: Türk Tarih Kurumu; 2010. (In Turkish and Persian).

12. Yusufi, Muhammad ‘Ali. Dar astana-yi tahqiq wa nashr: Fustat al-‘adala fi qawa‘id al-saltana. Faslnama-yi Ayina-yi mirath 2001;4(1): 56–58; available at: http://www.mirasmaktoob.ir/sites/default/files/archive/pdf/A13-Yoosefi-Edalat.pdf

13. Nizam al-Mulk. Siyar al-muluk (Siyasat-nama), ed. Mahmud ‘Abidi. Te-hran: Nashr-i sukhan; 1398/2019. (In Persian).

14. Danishyar, Murtaza. Siyar al-muluk-i Nizam al-Mulk: aghlat, maj‘ulat wa ‘amil-i anha. Pazhuhish-nama-yi tarikh-i tamaddun-i islami 1398/2019;52(1): 25–57; (In Persian); available at: https://journals.ut.ac.ir/article_75207.html

15. Ghereghlou, Kioumars. Kašf al-zonun. In: Encyclopædia Iranica, online edn.; available at: https://iranicaonline.org/articles/kasf-al-zonun

16. Hajji Khalifa. Kashf al-zunun ‘an asami al-kutub wa-l-funun. Bayrut: Dar Ihya’ al-turath al-‘arabi; 1941. (In Arabic); online edn. available at: https://al-maktaba.org/book/2118/9281

17. Khismatulin, A. Islamic Education Reflected in the Forms of Medieval Scholarly Literature: Jam‘, Ta’lif, and Tasnif in Classical Islam. In: Sebastian Günther (ed.). Knowledge and Education in Classical Islam: Religious Learning between Continuity and Change. Leiden: Brill; 2019. In 2 vols., i, p. 475–487; available at: https://orientalstudies.academia.edu/AlexeyKhismatulin

18. Khismatulin, A. Sochineniya imama al-Gazali. SPb.: Peterburgskoe vostokovedenie; M.: Sadra; 2017. Seriya: Nazidatel'naya literatura epokhi Saldzhukidov na persidskom yazyke: Originaly i poddelki (II); available at: https://orientalstudies.academia.edu/AlexeyKhismatulin

19. [Al-Ghazali, Muhammad.] Makatib-i farsi-yi Ghazzali ba nam-i Faza’il al-anam min rasa’il Hujjat al-Islam. Gardawaranda-yi yaki az mansuban-i wai, ed. by ‘Abbas Iqbal Ashtiyani. Tehran; 1363/1984. (In Persian).

20. Al-Kiya al-Harasi at web-site Markaz Abi’l-Hasan al-Ash‘ari. (In Arabic); available at: https://web.archive.org/web/20160304142312/http://www.achaari.ma/Article.aspx?C=5714

21. Al-Farisi, ‘Abd al-Ghafir. Al-Mukhtasar min kitab al-Siyaq li-Tarikh Nisabur, ed. Muhammad Kazim al-Mahmudi. Tehran: Markaz-i pazhuhishi-yi Mirath-i maktub; 1384/2005; (In Arabic); available at: https://ketabpedia.com/تحميل/المختصر-من-كتاب-السياق-لتاريخ-نيسابور/

22. Ibn Khallikan. Wafayat al-A‘yan wa Anba’ Abna’ al-Zaman. Bayrut; 1900-… (In Arabic); online edn. available at: https://al-maktaba.org/book/1000/1299#p1

23. ‘Abbas Iqbal Ashtiyani. Wazarat dar ‘ahd-i salatin-i buzurg-i Saljuqi az tarikh-i tashkil-i in silsila ta marg-i sultan-i Sanjar (432–552), ed. by M.-T. Danishpazhuh wa Y. Dhuka’. Tehran; 1338/1959. (In Persian).

24. Al-Dhahabi, Shams al-din. Siyar a‘lam al-nubala. Mu’assasat al-risala; 1405/1985; (In Arabic); online edn. available at: http://lib.eshia.ir/40384/19/351

25. Makdisi, George. Muslim institutions of learning in eleventh-century Baghdad. Bulletin of the SOAS 1961;24(1): 1–56.

26. Simidchieva, Marta. Kingship and Legitimacy in Nizam al-Mulk’s Siyasatnama, Fifth/Eleventh Century. In: Beatrice Gruendler & Louise Marlow (eds.). Writers and Rulers, Perspective on Their Relationship from Abbasid to Safavid Times. Wiesbaden: Reichert Verlag; 2004. P. 97–131; available at: https://yorku.academia.edu/MartaSimidchieva

27. Hanaway, William L. Secretaries, Poets, and the Literary Language. In: Brian Spooner & William L. Hanaway (eds.). Literacy in the Persianate World Writing and the Social Order. University of Pennsylvania Press; 2012. P. 95–142.

28. ‘Oudi, Sattar, & Murtaza Baqayi. Nigahi ba sarguzasht-i Ibn ‘Alqami, wapasin wazir-i shi‘ayi-yi ‘Abbasiyan. Tarikh-i farhang wa tamaddun-i islami 1391/2012;3(6): 101–120; (In Persian); available at: http://tarikh.maaref.ac.ir/article-1-1202-en.pdf

29. Khuyi, Hasan b. ‘Abd al-Mu’min Husam al-Din. Majmu‘a-yi athar-i Husam al-din Khuyi. Tehran: Mirath-i maktub; 2000. (In Persian).

30. Jackson, P. Ahmad Takudar. In: Encyclopædia Iranica, online edn.; available at: https://iranicaonline.org/articles/ahmad-takudar-third-il-khan-of-iran-r

31. Turan, Osman. Türkiye Selçukluları Hakkında Resmi Vesikalar. Ankara; 1958. Türk Tarih Kurumu Yayınları VII. Seri, No. 32. (In Turkish and Persian).

32. Aqsarayi, Mahmud b. Muhammad. Tarikh-i Salajiqa ya Musamarat al-akhbar wa musayarat al-akhyar, ed. Osman Turan. Tehran: Asatir; 1362/1983. (In Persian); available at: https://eliteraturebook.com/books/search/all/مسامرة

33. Histoire des Seldjoucides d'Asie Mineure d'après l'abrégé du Seldjouknameh d’Ibn Bibi. In: Recueil de textes relatifs à l'histoire des Seljoucides, iv, par M. Th. Houtsma. Leide: Brill; 1902. available at: https://archive.org/details/recueildetextesr03houtuoft/page/n807/mode/2up

34. Yazici, Tahsin. Ebn Bibi. In: Encyclopædia Iranica, online edn.; available at: http://www.iranicaonline.org/articles/ebn-bibi

35. Bigbabapur, Yusuf. Tuhfat al-muluk athari-yi nawyafta az Awhadi-yi Maraghayi. Ayina-yi mirath 1390/2011;9(48): 21–47; (In Persian); available at: http://ensani.ir/file/download/article/20121231090428-9611-54.pdf

36. Vafayi, Muhammad Afshin. Naqdi bar: Tuhfat al-muluk az Awhadi Maraghi. Bukhara, 1391/2012;15(86): 460–466; (In Persian); available at: https://www.academia.edu/6015292/

37. Al-Quda‘i, Muhammad b. Salama. Tarikh al-Quda‘i [al-ma‘ruf bi-]Kitab ‘Uyun al-ma‘arif wa-funun akhbar al-khala’if, ed. Muhammad al-Misri. Makka; 1415/1995. (In Arabic); available at: https://archive.org/details/1933p.d.f1760

38. Al-Quda‘i, Muhammad b. Salama. Kitab al-inba’ bi-anba’ al-anbiya’ wa-tawarikh al-khulafa’ wa-wilayat al-umara’ al-ma‘ruf bi-Tarikh al-Quda‘i, ed. ‘Umar Tadmuri. Bayrut: al-Maktabat al-‘asriyya; 1999. (In Arabic).

39. Ibn al-‘Imrani, Muhammad b. ‘Ali. Al-inba’ fi-tarikh al-khulafa’, ed. Taqi Binesh. Mashhad: Nashr-i Danish; 1363/1984. (In Arabic).

40. Ibn al-‘Imrani, Muhammad b. ‘Ali. Al-inba’ fi-tarikh al-khulafa’, ed. Qasim al-Samarayi. Qahira: Dar al-afaq al-‘arabiyya; 1419/1999. (In Arabic); available at: https://al-maktaba.org/book/12289

41. Bosworth, C. Administrative literature. In: M. Young, J. Latham, & R. Serjeant (eds.). Religion, Learning and Science in the ‘Abbasid Period. The Cambridge History of Arabic Literature. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 1990. P. 155–167; available at: https://archive.org/details/M.J.L.YoungJ.D.LathamR.B.SerjeantEdsReligionLearningAndScienceInTheAbbasidPeriod

42. Yıldız, Sara Nur. A Nadim for the Sultan. Rawandi and the Anatolian Seljuks. In: Peacock A. C. S. & Sara Nur Yıldız (eds.). The Seljuks of Anatolia: Court and Society in the Medieval Middle East. London; New York: I. B. Tauris; 2013. P. 91–111.

43. Komaily, Mokhtar. Rawandi, intihal ya iqtibas? Ayina-yi mirath 1387/2008;4(43): 150–162; (In Persian); available at: http://www.ensani.ir/fa/content/263519/default.aspx.

44. Orfali, Bilal. Employment opportunities in literature in tenth-century Islamic courts. In: Sabine Schmidtke (ed.). Studying the Near and Middle East at the Institute for Advanced Study, Princeton, 1935—2018, Piscataway, NJ: Gorgias Press; 2018. P. 243–250; available at: https://www.academia.edu/36407420/Employment_Opportunities_in_Literature_in_tenth-Century_Islamic_Courts.